Skip to content

What a heap of garbage

Published:

(This is an open letter to State Sens. Alan Lowenthal and Sheila Kuehl.) California has a disposal problem — last year we disposed more than 40 million tons of trash in landfills and through incinerators, putting the health and safety of future generations at risk, draining our economy and wasting precious resources. Right now, California has a choice: It can finally begin to kick the disposal habit using new technologies that can convert solid waste into products, fuels and electricity, or it can continue to dump trash into landfills and incinerators around the state. Each year this choice becomes more desperate as communities say “no” to new solid waste facilities near their homes. But a few misguided individuals are obstructing our ability to declare independence from disposal, and their doing it with the assistance of key legislators.

I understand from public sources that both of you: • Blocked passage of enabling legislation, AB 1090, still pending in the legislature, which would have given these technologies the level playing field they deserve in order to be considered. • Sided with a single simplistic environmental group, Californians Against Waste, instead of considering the testimony of dozens of experts, technology vendors, public officials, scientists and engineers, who are all clamoring for a positive paradigm shift in solid waste management that these technologies could bring. • Forced the governor’s appointees to the State Waste Board, by holding their confirmations hostage, to expunge the truth about these technologies from their recently adopted “Conversion Technology Report to the Legislature.” • Insisted that all recommendations and information not specifically required by the bill that requested this report be stricken from it.

Shame on both of you. Alan, you have been a champion in reducing pollution from our ports and using best available technology to do so. How can you now block technology that has been proven in Europe to effectively reduce the environmental impacts of landfills and incinerators for decades?

Sheila, you have been honored by the ACLU for your progressive stances, and I am now ashamed to admit that I was an enthusiastic participant/performer in that award ceremony. How can you now impose censorship on information that could improve our environment?

How could either of you stoop to extortion-like tactics that end up hurting our progress to improve the environment and create good, green jobs, all at the behest of such a narrow and misinformed special interest? Californians Against Waste probably means well, but they make wildly inaccurate statements such as “the diox-in from conversion technologies is more dangerous than nuclear waste.” Nuclear

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 12, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe