Skip to content

What to do? Capital expenditure vs. operating expense

Published:

By IN YOUR SPACE BY CHRISTINA S. PORTER

There are questions about what costs should be included in annual operating expense charges, fueled by an ongoing disagreement between landlords and tenants about which of them is responsible for the cost of capital expenditures and whether they should be included in the tenant “pass throughs.”

A “capital expenditure” is considered, in Generally Accepted Accounting Practices, as the cost of a building improvement that lasts beyond the current accounting period, which is one year; and/or, an item that increases the value or life of the asset. A suggestion by KBA Lease Services (Newsletter, November 2002) is to “think of Capital Expenditures as investments in a building that are intended to bring long term benefits.”

In general, operating expenses include: ■ Building maintenance ■ Power ■ Property management ■ Property taxes ■ Property insurance A distinction that should be noted is that a capital expenditure is different from a capital improvement. A capital improvement is a “new” (additional) improvement like a new security system. A capital expenditure is usually a replacement/refurbishment of an item that has worn out.

It makes sense that the base rent is meant to cover normal wear and tear of the building, and all of its parts, demonstrated by the fact that an owner is compensated for this normal wear and tear through depreciation of the building (asset) and all of its parts, by his ability to decrease his tax liability on an annual basis. Through the years the components of a building and the building itself, are expected to wear out and be replaced. At the very least, if an item must be replaced or added, and the cost of which cannot be negotiated out of the lease prior to execution, should be amortized over its useful life and then over the remaining term of the existing lease. It is the owner who will truly reap the long term benefit of such an improvement. The only time a capital expenditure should be included in operating expenses is if the improvement will reduce operating expenses, and even then, the cost should be amortized over the expected life of the asset and again over the remaining term of the existing lease.

The leases with which I am most familiar also address the possibility of government required capital expenditures. This could happen if the government’s applicable requirements change regarding a building and its type of use. An example of this type of expenditure would be government-mandated earthquake retrofitting. If any of you have done this to your building you know how expensive it can be. If the new laws are put in place during the term of a lease, requiring a significant amount of improvements to the building, and depending on the cost of the required improvements, the landlord may choose to: ■ Terminate the lease (with proper notice to the tenant) at which time the tenant may choose to pay for the improvements itself. ■ Pay for them and pass the cost through to the tenant (amortized over the useful life of the improvement and again over the remaining term of the tenant’s lease). There also is a provision for the government required improvements that might be triggered by the tenant’s “specific and unique use of the premises,” which puts the burden of paying for the improvements on the tenant, and depending at what point during the lease term this requirement arises and the amount of cash involved, the tenant may be able to terminate its lease. (Christina S. Porter is in the business of leasing and selling industrial and office buildings. She (310) 806-6104 or)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 18, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe