By Ed Silverstein
In 1984, a methyl isocyanate gas leak from a chemical plant in Bhopal, India claimed 20,000 lives. Many others were blinded or disabled and in all, 150,000 Indians suffered health effects.
And this was from a leak. Imagine the outcome had a group of terrorists blown up the plant, or worse, intentionally released tons of these deadly chemicals.
Of course this could never happen in the United States. George W. Bush has made homeland security his “top priority.”
If you believe either of these two statements, you would be wrong… perhaps even dead wrong.
Jonathan Chait, in his eye-opening article for The New Republic (3/10/03), details just how low a priority Bush has made Homeland Security. After anthrax attacks on Washington, the House Appropriations Committee’s ranking Democrat, David Obey, and ranking Republican, Bill Young, went to all major security agencies including the FBI, CIA, NSA and CDC.
From those meetings they determined the prime terrorist targets that remained vulnerable and were neglected during the initial $20 billion of homeland security spending. The two congressmen whittled down the list to those items deemed absolutely necessary for security, such as computer upgrades for the FBI, improved security for ports, air-lines and nuclear facilities. The total cost for the measures was $10 billion.
Obey and Young, along with their counterparts, Senators Byrd and Stevens, went to Bush with their proposal. Bush responded that he would veto any measure that proposed spending even one cent more than was already approved for homeland security. Bush then had Vice President Dick Cheney (successfully) lobby Republicans to not even allow debate on the Obey-Young proposal.
Bush has also vetoed several other cost-effective measures that would have strengthened security, including a $5.1 billion bill passed overwhelmingly by Congress.
The obvious question is: Why would Bush actively fight against security measures that would make you and I safer? The answer is simple: Tax cuts.
The first round of tax cuts will cause record deficits, possibly in excess of $400 billion a year. According to Chiat, even Republicans are becoming leery of voting for Bush’s new tax cut proposals. As a result, Bush is dead-set against anything that will increase the deficit and thus stymie further tax cuts, regardless of the human costs.
This leaves our ports, which receive 95 percent of the country’s imports, extremely vulnerable. Only 1 in 50 containers are inspected.
That means a biochemical weapon or a nuclear bomb in one of those containers has about a 98 percent chance of getting through. The Coast Guard has stated that it needs $1 billion immediately and $4.5 billion in the next 5 years to make the ports safe.
Bush doesn’t seem to care. There is also poor security at facilities that build and/or store nuclear materials and bombs.
Terrorists could steal radioactive materials or even capture and set off a nuclear bomb. This prompted Bush-appointed Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham to request $379 million to protect those weapons. The White House approved only $26 million, or a bare 7 percent of what was asked for.
Currently there are only 14 agents pursuing 1,200 illegal aliens from countries in which Al-Quaeda operates. The INS wants a mere $52 million to hire additional agents. Bush said no.
And it isn’t only new spending that the President is against.
Bush has cut 10 percent from the $1 billion the United States uses to secure risky Russian nuclear material and hire that country’s unemployed weapons scientists. This was despite a nonpartisan Energy Department study urging an increase to $3 billion.
Bush promised $3.5 billion in new funding for first responders, but only came up with $800 million in new funds. The rest was shifted from existing funds and grants already given to police and firefighters.
Bush’s new budget reduces spending on many previously approved homeland security measures or fails to fund programs Bush had publicly endorsed, such as the Container Security Initiative that would screen cargo at foreign ports. Bush has attempted to shift the blame to Congress, but in a March 6 letter, Republican Steve Young blasted White House officials, calling their statements factually inaccurate.
Bush has also obstructed corporate security legislation.
An article in the Daily News revealed that a chemical release from Matheson Tri- Gas facility in New Jersey could endanger 7.3 million people. Chemical facilities across the country, which Al- Quaeda has studied, could affect many times that number. But Bush and fellow Republicans, kowtowing to an intense lobbying effort by chemical companies, voted down a bill by Senator Corzine to require those companies to increase security standards.
Bush also refuses to consider bans of 50-caliber sniper rifles that can take down an airliner as effectively and with greater ease than a shoulder launched rocket.
America is about to go to war. It is almost certain this will result in increased terrorism. And while I like having a few more dollars as much as anyone, and probably benefit from tax cuts more than most, that extra money won’t do me a bit of good if I’m blind, disabled or dead.
We need these security measures now. And all can be easily funded if the President is willing to roll back just a small part of his tax cut. But it seems Bush’s top priority — maybe his only priority — is to have tax cuts that predominantly make the rich rich-er. Even if it kills us. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. Comments and confessions from atoning Bush supporters will be accepted at:)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 19, 2003. Read the original PDF.