By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN
“Intelligence Community” is apparently a misnomer.
According to the presidential committee’s scathing report, the CIA, DIA, FBI and NSA combined couldn’t find a clandestine WMD program if it bit them on the ass. And despite the supposed goal of intelligence coordinating relegated to the Department of Homeland Security and now the new national intelligence director, the level of communication between intelligence agencies is a little worse than Michael Shiavo and Robert Schindler.
But as disturbing as the report’s conclusions, which suggest that the security of the United States has been entrusted to the Keystone Cops, this is only the B story. The A story is in a report that you haven’t yet seen.
In July 2004, the Senate Intelligence Committee released the results of its investigations into pre-war intelligence failures that lambasted the various agencies for incompetence and lack of communication. Unfortunately it included only five of 10 areas examined. The reason that we saw those five at all and only saw those five had to do with a deal brokered (or extorted) by the majority republicans.
Republicans on the committee were terrified that if the rest of the investigation, which included Bush Administration pressure on intelligence assessments, and the distortions and misrepresentations of those assessments by the administration, were revealed prior to the election, Bush would have had about as much chance of being reelected as Michael Jackson has of being named musical director of the Vienna Boy’s Choir. Republicans attempted to block the release of the entire report until after the election, but ultimately brokered a deal with democrats, issuing the first half of the report in July, with a promise to release the remainder in early 2005.
Which reminds me of a joke. How can you tell when a republican is lying? His lips are moving.
Of course, it is not necessary to read a report to understand the motivations and machinations of the Bush Administration. According to former Treasury Secretary Paul O’Neil, from the moment the Bush Administration took office, Iraq was a war looking for an excuse. 9/11 gave them that excuse. However, they still needed to convince the American people that waging war over what was little more than a large gas station was worth hundreds of billions of dollars and, to date, more than 1,500 American lives and thousands of Iraqi lives. In other words, they had to make Americans mad and scared.
For that they would need to get the intelligence community on board. But how do you get a highly a fractious and independent assortment of agencies behind questionable assertions?
For starters, you make sure they understand that dissent will not be tolerated. In this respect the Bushkies were tyrannical and vindictive. Anyone who dared challenge the administration was virtually assured of termination (former treasury Secretary Paul O’Neill) character assassination, (Richard Clark, John Kerry) or even having his or her life put in jeopardy (Valerie Plame).
Of course CIA director George Tenent, a Clinton appointed holdover, was no slouch at reading the handwriting on the wall. He understood full well that if he didn’t tow the party line he would be making sure the door didn’t hit him on the way out. Tenant’s sycophantic shift occurred fast enough to have caused whiplash. The CIA director went from someone who was warning caution to one ignoring warnings, specifically about the credibility of his sources.
But when even threats of unemployment (or death) were not sufficient to compel a few CIA analysts to rubberstamp the more outrageous of the Bush camp’s claims, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld set up a shadow intelligence group within the Pentagon. The effect was two fold: A) it gave the Administration a pliable source of intelligence to bolster their claims and B) the CIA, fearing loss of relevance, shifted their analysis to more reflect the administration views.
Compounding all of this was Ahmed Chalabis. Chablis, who was head of the Iraqi National Congress, was the darling of the same Bush neo-cons who were foaming at the mouth to go to war with Iraq. Despite a sorted past, that included a bank embezzlement conviction, and warnings about his character from both the State Department and the CIA, the Bush administration endorsed Chalabis as the man to take the reins in Iraq after Saddam’s ouster. The administration ushered him from one intelligence agency to another and it was Chalabis’ information and sources that provided the basis for nearly all intelligence concerning Iraq’s WMD programs.
The administration proceeded to spin, exaggerate and misrepresent the intelligence that originated from Chalabis to make their case for war. With the help of Fox News, right wing pundits and other conservative vehicles, they intentionally attempted to mislead the country into believing that there was a tie between Iraq and al Qaeda, that Saddam was involved in the 9/11 attacks, and that a nuclear or bio/chemical attack was imminent. (For specifics read Congressman Waxman’s report “Iraq On The Record” available on his Web site www.house.gov/waxman) Of course once the war ended, the White House’s golden haired boy quickly fell out of favor when it was learned that he was actually spying on the U.S. for axis of evil member, Iran. Further, nearly every shred of intelligence he provided has been discredited and his informants, such as the infamous Curveball, have been deemed unreliable if not down right insane. Of course rather than take the blame, Bush, a born-again Christian, emulated the disciple Peter who denied (read lied) knowing Jesus, though it was tougher for the president since there was extensive videotape of Chalabis featured prestigiously behind the first lady during the president’s state of the union address.
Of course if you’re waiting to read all this in paperback, don’t hold your breath. Republicans have recently decided to put the second half of their report on hold … indefinitely. (To reach Ed, e-mail to)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 6, 2005. Read the original PDF.