By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN
So begins what has been dubbed the “Secret Downing Street Memo.” The memo, which was leaked to the London Sunday Times, was written by British national security aide Matthew Rycroft and based on notes from a July 2002 meeting during which British Prime Minister Tony Blair discussed the Bush Administration policy in Iraq with his advisors.
The memo, what many have called “The Smoking Gun,” was written when Saddam Hussein was making what we all considered the outrageous claim that he had no weapons of mass destruction and that President Bush was intent on going to war, regardless. It was written before the U.N. arms inspectors returned to Iraq in a vain search for WMDs. It was written when liberals, warning that Bush & Co.: a) were manipulating intelligence, b) were really only interested in Iraqi oil and war profiteering and c) had no end game, a fact which would likely lead to chaos, were labeled as hysterical, unpatriotic, and even traitorous.
“C reported on his recent talks in Washington. There was a perceptible shift in attitude. Military action was now seen as inevitable. BUSH WANTED TO REMOVE SADDAM, THROUGH MIL- ITARY ACTION, JUSTIFIED BY THE CONJUNCTION OF TERRORISM AND WMD. BUT THE INTELLI- GENCE AND FACTS WERE BEING FIXED AROUND THE POLICY (emphasis added). The NSC had no patience with the UN route, and no enthusiasm for publishing material on the Iraqi regime’s record. THERE WAS LITTLE DISCUSSION IN WASHINGTON OF THE AFTERMATH AFTER MILITARY ACTION.” (emphasis added) These same “crazy liberals” claimed that Bush was forcing the timing of the war in order to gain a political advantage for Republicans.
“The Defense Secretary said that the U.S. had already begun ‘spikes of activity’ to put pressure on the regime. No decisions had been taken, but he thought THE MOST LIKELY TIMING IN U.S. MINDS FOR MILITARY ACTION TO BEGIN WAS JANUARY, WITH THE TIMELINE BEGINNING 30 DAYS BEFORE THE US CONGRESSIONAL ELECTIONS.” (emphasis added).
Further, liberals claimed that Iraq did-n’t represent as great a threat as North Korea or Iran and, in any event, the war was illegal.
“It seemed clear that Bush had made up his mind to take military action... BUT THE CASE WAS THIN. SADDAM WAS NOT THREATENING HIS NEIGHBOURS, AND HIS WMD CAPABILITY WAS LESS THAN THAT OF LIBYA, NORTH KOREA OR IRAN (emphasis added). We should work up a plan for an ultimatum to Saddam to allow back in the UN weapons inspectors. This would also help with the legal justification for the use of force.”
“This record is extremely sensitive. No further copies should be made. It should be shown only to those with a genuine need to know its contents.”
“The Attorney-General said that the DESIRE FOR REGIME CHANGE WAS NOT A LEGAL BASE FOR MILITARY ACTION” (emphasis added).
The Downing Street Memo proves that Bush and his cadre of neo-cons manipulated the U.S. into an illegal and unnecessary war. In their haste to take out Saddam and reap the war spoils they ignored cautions from the State Department and other officials that they were moving forward without a viable plan for the peace.
Today we are mired in Iraq, hemorrhaging money as our troops and civilian contractors are being killed and seriously wounded, with little to show for it. Conditions continue to deteriorate, infrastructure is in worse shape then before the war, the newly elected government has become paralyzed by internal squabbles, and the insurgency — which some are now calling a civil war — seems to escalate on a daily basis.
And let’s not forget how Republicans castigated liberals when they suggested that Bush’s $80 billion price tag for the war was a bigger fantasy then his claim that you could cut taxes without increasing the deficit. Already the war’s price tag has hit $280 billion with no end in sight.
And when liberals decried billions of no-bid contracts to Bush/Cheney corporate donors such as Halliburton, they were called fear mongers. Now every day brings a new report of some instance of corporate rape, corruption and incompetence. Billions of our tax dollars have been siphoned off in over billing schemes by the likes of Halliburton subsidiary Kellogg Brown & Root. Billions more have simply gone A.W.O.L., vanishing into thin air.
Taking all of this into consideration, one would think that the Downing Street Memo would have led a dozen network news cycles or been splattered on the front pages of the ubiquitous media outlets deemed liberal by the conservative propaganda machine. Hardly. With the exception of the New York Times, the Downing Street Memo barely received passing mention, if at all. The same fate befell Greg Palast’s investigative report that provided compelling evidence that Jeb Bush did, in fact, fix the 2000 Florida elections by illegally purging 90,000 blacks from the voter rolls. But, like the Downing Street Memo, it was up to a London paper to break Palast’s story, which was virtually ignored by the American mainstream.
Maybe the American press is cowed by the disingenuous Republican invective claiming the media is liberal. More likely, they are pandering to the conservative corporate interests that have purchased nearly all of our media outlets. Or maybe they just don’t believe that Americans care. One thing is certain: If you want to know what this government is up to, you better look to the British.
Or you could just start listening to the liberals. (Ed Silverstein)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 25, 2005. Read the original PDF.