By Cathie Mostovoy CEO, Woodcraft Rangers
Imagine if Ozzie and Harriet Nelson or Ward and June Cleaver could see the American family today. Instead of the “Leave it to Beaver” and “Ozzie and Harriet,” work-a-day dad and stay-at-home-mom model, today’s sitcom resembles the latch-key kid and the television set, and the vast majority of working families have no parent at home when kids get out of school. In fact, less than a quarter of America’s families fit that one-parent-works, one stays-home model.
In truth, the Nelsons and the Cleavers of the 1950s and early 1960s were never entirely representative of America’s families. However, there’s no question that the 21st century’s average kid’s post-school day is very different than it was when Ike was in the White House, Sputnik was circling the earth, and Marilyn Monroe was the biggest star in movie theaters.
Today’s working families — those in which either the sole parent or both parents work outside the home — face very real challenges between 3 p.m. and 6 p.m. during the school year, and in the summertime. Ask a group of moms and dads how their kids spend their time out of school, and you’ll hear a great variety of answers. Lots of kids have patchwork schedules — one afternoon or day with a relative, the next with a neighbor, the next at soccer practice, the next on their own or with a younger sibling. The parents, consumed with working in our factories, shops and offices to put dinner on the table and pay for school supplies find themselves consumed with incessant worry as well: Are they adequately supervised? Are they getting safely from one place to another? Are they really home doing homework, or have they slipped out to hang with friends, and what kind of friends?
Things would be easier if all working families had access to afterschool and summer programs for their kids. Unfortunately, few do. According to the most comprehensive survey research done to date on afterschool issues, “America After 3 PM: A Household Survey on Afterschool in America,” conducted for the Afterschool Alliance with support from the J.C. Penney Co., Inc., only 11 percent of the nation’s youth are in afterschool programs, while 25 percent are left to fend for themselves in the afternoons. The numbers of unsupervised children during summer may be even higher.
For working families, the percentage of latch-key children is even more striking. In these households, a full 31 percent of K-12 children (11.5 million) take care of themselves in the afternoons, while just 14 percent are in afterschool programs.
Not every child needs to be in an afterschool or summer program. But every parent ought to have that option available. Unfortunately, this is rarely the case. According to the survey, the parents of 15.3 million children would enroll their children in an afterschool program if one were available. The unavailability of afterschool care hits close to home, too: Across California, according to America After 3 PM, the parents of 37 percent of children not already in afterschool care say they’d enroll their children if a program were available.
Closing this afterschool gap is critical to our families and communities. In May, I was proud to join more than 500 afterschool advocates from around the country in carrying that message to our lawmakers in Washington. In meetings with members of Congress and their staff members, we discussed the profound and positive difference afterschool and summer programs make in the lives of our children — inspiring them to learn, keeping them safe, and helping their working parents. In addition, we presented hard data about the critical shortage of afterschool care.
Later this summer, Congress will decide whether to increase funding for afterschool programs, or to extend a four-year long budget freeze. The No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 called for slow but steady annual funding increases for the 21st Century Community Learning Centers initiative, which is the principle federal funding stream for afterschool. If that roadmap had been followed, the coming year’s appropriation for afterschool would be $2.25 billion. Instead, the president has proposed just under $1 billion — less than half of the No Child Left Behind commitment. As a result, some 1.75 million children will be without the afterschool care so critical to their safety and development.
If Ozzie, Harriet, Ward, and June were raising their kids today, chances are that some of them would need an afterschool or summer program. That’s the reality for America’s working families in 2005. When it comes to afterschool, living in the past is hurting our kids.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 7, 2005. Read the original PDF.