By Jodi Summers
Homeowners’ insurance provides financial protection against disasters. A standard policy insures your home and the things you keep in it. Every home with a mortgage has to have insurance. The problem is, rates keep going up.
A study by the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America found that 51 million homeowners are paying higher premiums than they did two years ago. Of that group, 23 percent pay 11 to 25 percent more, while 13.8 percent have seen their rates increase by more than 25 percent.
“The reason for significant premium increases is multi-layered,” said Eugene Solomon, an insurance broker in El Segundo. “Mostly the increases can be attributed to poor underwriting results and poor investment returns. A company can pay out in claims more than it takes in as long as the premiums held for investment perform adequately. In the late ‘90s, companies could secure double-digit investment returns. As a consequence, a bidding war raged, lowering auto and home premiums. When investment results deteriorated in the early 2000s the ratio became distorted. Companies were now dipping into reserve accounts which can create instability.”
“Mostly the increases can be attributed to poor underwriting results and poor investment returns. A company can pay out in claims more than it takes in as long as the premiums held for investment perform adequately.” — — EUGENE SOLOMON Insurance broker
An entity has been established to help bring the costs down and help homeowners.
“We are concerned that increased costs will affect people’s ability to get into the market,” notes Marcia Salkin, who is part of an insurance task force created by the National Association of Realtors to address problems with homeowners’ insurance. “We’re seeing people who think they have insurance and then after they close on their house find out that the company won’t give them insurance after all.”
A standard homeowner’s insurance policy includes four essential types of coverage. They include: ■Coverage for the structure of your home. ■Coverage for your personal belongings. ■Liability protection. ■Additional living expenses in the event you are temporarily unable to live in your home because of a fire or another insured disaster. Damage caused by most disasters is covered but there are exceptions — earthquake insurance requires another policy.
In 2000, insurers paid out $1.11 in claims for every $1 they collected in premiums and in 2001 they paid out $1.16 in claims for every $1 collected, according to Don Griffin of the National Association of Independent Insurers.
“At that point they had to raise premiums and go back and re-examine all of their policy holders because they can’t afford to pay out more than they collect,” Griffin said.
The bottom line is causing insurers to become more cost efficient in their choices. Escalating repair costs and the increase in mold-related claims have made it more expensive for them to do business.
“Mold claims and negative underwriting results have all been alleged by company spokespeople as the primary reason for the rapid run-up,” Solomon said. “The companies now raise rates to compensate. However, any increase of over 6.9 percent must be approved in a public hearing. Companies have three choices: Several 6.9 percent increases over the course of the year, or a public battle with the insurance commissioner — who is not industry friendly — or remove themselves from the marketplace.
State Farm & 21st Century Insurance removed themselves from the market-place. Farmers Insurance and Allstate took a series of small increases. Safeco began a battle with the insurance commissioner, which began with a requested 19.7 percent increase. This was rejected and Safeco withdrew from the market. The request has now been reduced to 10 percent in exchange for re-entry into the market. When a company like State Farm removes itself, 25 percent of the market goes as well. This creates a strain on demand and the prices go up even more rapidly.”
Next week, we will cover ways that may help you save money on your homeowner’s insurance. (If you would like to more information of interest to property owners, , or call at (310) 309-4219).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 1, 2003. Read the original PDF.