By Rebecca Bushman and Margie Delano Santa Monica
Let me begin by saying that the Santa Monica Daily Press has and continues to do a wonderful job of keeping the citizens of Santa Monica well informed and entertained. I read this paper religiously and thoroughly enjoy every issue.
I am writing today in reply to an article written on June 27 by a Mr. Frank Armstrong. I am a waitress currently working at a reputable restaurant on Wilshire Boulevard. I, as well as many of my colleagues, took offense to the tone and accusations of Mr. Armstrong in his article. We wish today to clarify and refute the arguments made in his letter last month.
I would like to first recognize the fact that I in no way condone the actions of the waiter that would not serve a customer because he did not leave a tip. The waiter’s actions were reprehensible; he clearly acted poorly in that situation. Obviously tipping is not an obligation nor should it be. Food servers are aware of this. However, it must also be understood that, although not mandatory, tipping does ensure fast and expeditious service.
Let’s take a moment to recount the origin and history of tipping. T.I.P.S. in the food industry originally meant “To Insure Prompt Service.” For many generations now, tipping has been common practice in many professions. For example, if a person goes to a bar and orders a drink, a smart customer will immediately tip the bartender.
Because the bartender knows that this particular customer tips, he is more likely to pay more attention to this customer and make sure he is happy. This is because the bartender is repaying the customer for the tip that he received as well as hoping for a tip on future visits. The customer therefore ensures promptness as well personal attention by tipping the bartender.
The same is true in hotels when one tips a bellhop to ensure expeditious service in and out of the hotel. It is no wonder then that “tips” have become common practice for professions that may require extra personal attention.
Tipping has become socially accepted within our society. It’s not obligatory but don’t expect great service or even decent service if you’re not willing to pay for it. This is the way it works.
To prove even further that tipping is a socially expected practice let it be known that the government taxes all waitresses and waiters on their total food sales. Each server will be taxed on 8 percent of his or her total food sales for the year. This proves that the government expects that every food server will be getting this amount as a minimum bonus for his or her work in a restaurant.
Although tipping is not mandatory the government taxes us; this tax is, in fact, mandatory. In fact, the IRS is considering raising the taxable income to 15 percent. If the government is expecting to tax us 15 percent, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect that from our customers.
In his letter last week, Mr. Armstrong mentioned that other professions that serve the public — i.e. firemen, police men, mail men, etc. — do not get tips for fulfilling their duties to the community. However, I must make some clear distinctions as well as point out the faulty logic in his claim.
First let me say that all of the professions he listed either required college level education or are run by our government. This is important because these professions cannot be classified on the same level as those of food servers. Since when did a teacher, being paid $50,000 a year, need to be tipped by a student? Why would a policeman, who has all of his dental and medical bills paid for by insurance, ask to be compensated by the people for all of his work? Not very many food servers receive medical, dental and a lucrative paycheck. One must understand the contrast between the jobs listed by Mr. Armstrong and that of a food server. Let me list a few of my own people who do in fact get tipped for there services and were not on the list given last month: Golf caddies, Taxi drivers, Salon stylists, Bellmans and Bartenders.
Let me make one more clarification about the distinction between waitresses and say that of a mailman. A mailman’s job does not require the level of customer service that the job of a waitress demands. A mailman does not have to return your mail and get you a new package if the edges are bent; but a waitress does have to bring you new eggs if the first ones were runny.
And, say that you are in a hurry and need to get your food quickly — no mailman is going to make sure that you get your mail before anyone else does, at least, not without an extra fee. If a customer wants to substitute hash browns for fruit, wants their hamburger Cajun style, doesn’t like the ketchup to be on the same plate with the French fries, wants a lemon in their soda — a waitress makes sure all of that happens the way you want it. No other profession has to take care of their customers in such a manner. Because of this it has become customary for customers to tip their waiter for that special service.
I don’t believe that a customer should get lesser service because they do not tip but I will admit that NO ONE will give a person great service repeatedly if he is known not to tip well. That’s just human nature.
Although not mandatory, we find alarming the contempt that Mr. Armstrong feels for the waiters and waitresses and their profession. We hope that this letter will help clarify that we do not always expect a tip but we also hope this gives clear reasoning of why a tip is appropriate and essential to all food servers.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 15, 2002. Read the original PDF.