Skip to content

‘Wimpy’ state budget fattens college system

Published:

By SHEILA KUEHL

(Editor’s note: This is the sixth article in a series by Sen. Sheila Kuehl (D-Santa Monica) on the ongoing state budget crisis).

There are three systems of public higher education in California: The University of California (UC) system, the California State University (CSU) system and all the community colleges. The master plan for higher education in California, adopted in 1960, established a percentage system so that every Californian wishing to attend a public college in the state and qualified to do so would be admitted. It was, and remains, the underpinning of California’s promise to its high school graduates.

UC is supposed to take the top 12.5 percent of graduates, as well as the top 4 percent of graduates from each high school. UC also is the primary state-supported academic agency for research of all kinds and for research and instruction in the professional fields of law, medicine, dentistry and veterinary medicine. CSU is supposed to take those who place in the top 33.3 percent of high school graduates and the community colleges are to educate everyone else.

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger’s January budget: UC and CSU: In the budget sent to the Legislature in January, in addition to deep cuts already taken and fee increases already made in the 2003-04 budget, Gov. Schwarzenegger proposed deeper cuts to higher education. ■ New freshman enrollment was to be reduced at UC and CSU by 10 percent (about 7,000 freshmen) by “redirecting” these qualified students to the community colleges. These students were to be promised admission in some UC or CSU campus as juniors. ■ Even though we will see a 2 percent increase in those graduating from high school this June, the budget contained no additional funding for growth. This means an additional 5,000 freshmen at UC and more than 16,000 students will not be admitted at CSU. ■ Although the budget proposed a cap for increases of student fees at 10 percent per year (more than doubling the 2004 fee by 2013), Gov. Schwarzenegger proposed much higher increases over the next two years. Although the Regents and the Trustees must vote on fee increases, Gov. Schwarzenegger simply reduces the budgets by the amount he proposes they recapture by raising fees. ■ Although the budget increases the costs for students to attend UC and CSU, there is a significant reduction in financial aid, the first time these issues have gone in different directions. Under long-standing practice, when fees are raised one-third of new revenue is devoted to student aid, so that students qualified to go but unable to pay can still get in.

Gov. Schwarzenegger proposed that only 20 percent of the new revenue generated by increased student fees would go to financial aid, shutting out more families unable to pay the increased tuition, which at UC would go over $6,000 a year and, at CSU, would go over $2,200. Graduate student fees were increased far more, by 40 percent, (in reality a further cut to the university since many graduate students’ fees are waived if they serve as teaching assistants). ■ Outreach to underrepresented students was eliminated. ■ Student-faculty ratios were increased so classes would be larger. ■ Professional schools were supposed to move toward privatization — no public funding-full funding by fees and/or research. ■ The proposed budget reduced support for libraries by 7.5 percent.

Although the community colleges, unlike the UC and CSU systems, did not receive any mid-year cuts in the 2003-04 budget, Gov. Schwarzenegger’s budget proposed another increase in student fees. In 2003-04, the fees went from $11 per unit to $18 per unit, and the new budget raises them to $26 per unit. Students who already have a BA in anything but want further education in the community colleges would pay $50 per unit, presumably burdening those re-entering the workforce or participating in job re-training programs. ■ The true situation at the community colleges remains unclear, however. Last September, the community colleges reported that 90,000 fewer students accessed the colleges than might have in 2003-04. The Legislative Analyst’s office says it was really “only” 17,000 who decided, because of fees, or because of their inability to access classes that were cut from the curriculum or oversubscribed and closed, not to even apply. Growth was not funded so the colleges were forced to provide fewer classes. Although the master plan does not allow capping enrollment, the actions of closing classes and raising fees has caused a decline in the numbers of students. • The “re-directing” of UC qualified students to community colleges displaces thousands who could have gone.

Gov. Schwarzenegger’s decision to freeze certain amounts in the May revision also affected higher education. Fearful that the Legislature, which was attempting to restore monies to the UC and CSU budgets, would be unsuccessful, the president of the UC system and the chancellor of the CSU system met with Gov. Schwarzenegger and agreed to: ■ Swallow more than $700 million in cuts in the next budget year. ■ Push the regents and the trustees to adopt a 14 percent increase in student fees. ■ Increase graduate fees by 20 percent, not the proposed 40 percent.

Gov. Schwarzenegger agreed to: ■ Boost UC and CSU’s base budgets by at least 3 percent starting next year and through 2011. ■ Back away from strict enrollment limits. ■ Provide funding for 5,000 more students at UC and 8,000 for CSU starting in the 2005-06 budget. (Some called it the “Wimpy” budget, recalling the Popeye character who was known for saying “I will gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today.”) The Legislature is not a party to the “deal” Gov. Schwarzenegger apparently struck with UC and CSU, and is, in no way, bound by it. Rather, adamant that higher education is one of the drivers of the greatness of California, not only in the development, retention and success of its high-tech businesses but also in its promise of a college education to every qualified high school graduate, the Legislature voted to reject many of the proposed cuts and the “deal.”

The changes adopted by the Legislature go into the Budget Conference Committee and negotiations with the Governor continue. Members of the Legislature in both houses are extremely critical of the proposed cuts to higher education and are committed to restoring funds for these programs without further harming social services or health programs. Obviously, this requires cuts in other programs (prisons, tax credits which are not serving their purported purposes), as well as an increase in fees and, perhaps, some taxes.

Interestingly, the greatest burdens of the proposed budget fall on working-and middle-class Californians. They might even refer to their increased financial burdens as taxes. The Governor has indicated that all will share the pain equally. The discussions of just what that means will continue.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 20, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe